Buying new tires doesn't have to break the bank. If you're at the comparison stage of your tire-buying journey, you’re likely hunting for affordable tire deals that offer both low prices and great value. In this post, we’ll compare deals from four major U.S. tire retailers – Mavis Discount Tire, Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and SimpleTire – to help you find the best place to get new tires. We’ll look at pricing, warranties, seasonal discounts, and what real customers say, all in a friendly, casual tone (with a dash of authority) to guide you to the right choice.
Need tools for your project? Toolbox, a tool rental marketplace, might be worth a look.
Why Compare Tire Deals?
Not all tire sellers are the same. Some offer price match guarantees, others include free services like rotations or road-hazard warranties. Many run seasonal sales or rebates that can save you extra money. By comparing what each retailer offers in terms of pricing, warranty, discounts, and customer satisfaction, you can make an informed decision and get the best value for your money. Let’s dive into the top options and see how they stack up.
Mavis Discount Tire
Mavis Discount Tire (often just called Mavis) is a large brick-and-mortar tire chain known for its budget-friendly prices (the word “Discount” is in their name!). With over 1,400 stores nationwide, they’re especially common in the Eastern and Midwestern US. Here’s what Mavis offers:
-
Price & Deals: Mavis promises the “guaranteed lowest price” on tires. They have a 30-day price match guarantee – if you find the same tire cheaper within 30 days after purchase, Mavis will refund the difference plus 5%. That means they not only match a competitor’s price but beat it by 5%, putting a bit of money back in your wallet. Mavis also partners with tire manufacturers on rebates. For example, there are rebates up to \$180 back on select Goodyear tire sets and up to \$100 on select Hankook tire sets. These deals usually require a mail-in or online rebate form, but they can make a big dent in the total cost. In addition, Mavis often posts coupons for services and seasonal promotions on their website – so it pays to check their “Deals” page for any current tire coupons or holiday sales.
-
Warranty & Services: When you buy tires from Mavis, you get some nice perks. They include free tire rotations for the life of the tires, helping you maximize tire lifespan at no extra cost. If you want extra protection, road hazard coverage is available for purchase – this can cover things like flat repairs or tire replacements if you hit a nasty pothole. Mavis is a full-service shop, so you can also get your tires installed and balanced on-site, and even get other car maintenance (like alignments, brakes, oil changes) done while you’re there. This one-stop-shop convenience is a plus for many busy drivers.
-
Customer Experience: As a large chain, Mavis’s customer reviews can vary by location. Many customers appreciate the fast service and low prices at Mavis. You’ll find positive feedback about getting tires fixed on short notice and friendly staff at certain stores. However, experiences can differ – some locations may try to upsell services, and independent ratings for Mavis aren’t quite as high as some competitors. (For instance, Mavis didn’t top the charts in a recent Consumer Reports tire retailer satisfaction survey, whereas others did.) The takeaway? It’s a good idea to check the reviews of your local Mavis store. Overall, if you have a Mavis shop nearby and they’re running a great rebate on the tires you need, it could be an excellent affordable option for your new tires.
👉 Mavis Tip: Before you buy, visit Mavis’s website or call your local shop to see what current tire deals or coupons are available. A little research can often save you extra cash on top of their already low prices.
Discount Tire (America’s Tire)
Discount Tire (known as “America’s Tire” in some states) is one of the nation’s largest tire retailers, with over 1,000 stores across the U.S. They’ve built a strong reputation for both value and customer service. Here’s how Discount Tire stands out in the search for affordable tire deals:
-
Price & Deals: Discount Tire is serious about competitive pricing. They maintain a low-price promise on all the tires and wheels they sell. In practice, if you find a lower price for the same tire locally, they’ll typically match or beat it – just let them know. Discount Tire also frequently offers seasonal promotions and rebates. For example, during a recent promotion, they advertised “up to \$80 off instantly on select sets of 4 Michelin tires” combining manufacturer savings and exclusive discounts. They run similar deals for other major brands (like Bridgestone, Goodyear, BFGoodrich, and more) especially around holidays or peak tire-buying seasons. Keep an eye out for sales like Black Friday, spring promotions, or summer road-trip specials – these can knock significant dollars off a new set of tires. Discount Tire also offers financing options (via a store credit card) which can help if you want to pay over time, though we’re focusing on upfront savings here.
-
Warranty & Services: One big advantage of buying from Discount Tire is the suite of free services you get. If you purchase your tires from them, you receive free rotation, balancing, air pressure checks, flat repairs, and tire safety inspections for the life of the tires. In fact, they’re known to repair flats for free, even for people who didn’t buy their tires there, as a goodwill service. This can save you money and hassle down the road. Discount Tire also offers an optional Road Hazard Warranty (Certificate) at an extra charge – this protection covers damage to your tires (like non-repairable punctures) and will replace the tire if something happens. It’s essentially a replacement warranty; while it costs extra, many customers find peace of mind in it. (By contrast, Tire Rack includes a similar protection free with purchase, which we’ll discuss later.) Another thing to note: Discount Tire focuses solely on tires and wheels. They do not perform alignments, oil changes, or other auto repairs. The upside is they’re tire specialists; the downside is you’ll have to go elsewhere for any service beyond tires. On the whole, their installation package and after-sale service are top-notch for keeping your tires in great shape.
-
Customer Reviews: Discount Tire consistently earns high marks for customer satisfaction. In Consumer Reports surveys, Discount Tire (and its sister brand America’s Tire) was rated among the top tire retailers in the nation. Customers frequently praise their friendly, knowledgeable staff and quick service. The company’s culture emphasizes making customers happy – you’ll see this in little touches like checking torque on lug nuts, offering free tire rotations, and honoring their price guarantees with no hassle. Whether you walk into a store or buy online for in-store pickup, the experience is often smooth and reassuring. This strong track record is a big part of the “value” you get at Discount Tire – it’s not just about price, but confidence that you’ll be taken care of.
👉 Discount Tire Tip: Watch for instant savings events on Discount Tire’s website. For example, you might find a deal like “Get \$80 off a set of Goodyear tires (no rebate needed)” during a special sale. These limited-time deals can yield big savings. Also, don’t hesitate to mention a competitor’s price – Discount Tire will usually match it to ensure you get the best deal.
Tire Rack
Tire Rack is a legendary name in the online tire business. In fact, they were pioneers of selling tires online over 40 years ago. Now part of the Discount Tire family (they were acquired in 2021, though they still operate under their own name), Tire Rack offers an e-commerce experience with a huge selection of tires, wheels, and related accessories. If you’re comfortable buying online, Tire Rack has a lot to offer in terms of affordable deals and extras:
-
Price & Deals: Tire Rack’s prices are very competitive with other online retailers. They might not always be the rock-bottom absolute cheapest on every tire, but they make up for it with extras included in the price. Notably, every tire purchase comes with free 2-year road hazard protection (covering repairs or pro-rated replacement for flats and damage). That’s a built-in value (worth about \$10-\$20 per tire) you’d normally have to pay extra for elsewhere. Tire Rack also offers free shipping on most orders, delivering to your home or directly to a local installer. They often can deliver extremely fast – sometimes next-day – because they have warehouses around the country. When it comes to promotions, Tire Rack passes along all the major manufacturer rebates and sales. For instance, if Goodyear is running a rebate of “get up to \$80 back on a set of four tires,” Tire Rack will prominently advertise that and help you redeem it. They maintain a Deals section on their site where you can find current rebate offers, closeout sales, and package specials. While Tire Rack might not slash the base price of a tire as much as some flash-sale sites, the combination of fair pricing with free shipping and free hazard warranty means the overall cost can be very affordable for the value you receive.
-
Installation & Convenience: Since Tire Rack is online-only, you won’t be driving to a Tire Rack store (unless you live near their lone Indiana center). Instead, you order on their website and choose where to ship the tires. Tire Rack has a network of 10,000+ partner installers nationwide. During checkout, you can select a local mechanic or tire shop from their network, and Tire Rack will ship your tires directly there. The installer will then contact you to schedule installation. This makes the process pretty seamless – you purchase the tires at a great price, and a professional near you handles the install for a set fee. Tire Rack also has a customer-friendly 30-day return policy: if you’re not happy with your tires, or if you ordered the wrong size, you can return or exchange them (as long as they haven’t been driven on too much). That return window adds reassurance when buying sight-unseen.
-
Customer Reviews: Tire Rack has earned a loyal following over decades and enjoys an excellent reputation. In fact, Consumer Reports grouped TireRack.com together with Discount Tire in its top-rated tire sellers list – meaning customers are generally very satisfied with their Tire Rack experience. The site is well-known for its extensive reviews and research: you can read thousands of customer reviews on each tire model and even see results from Tire Rack’s own tire testing. This wealth of information helps buyers feel confident in their purchase. Shipping is generally quick and reliable, and issues (like a rare warranty claim or return) are usually handled efficiently. The main “complaint” some might have is the extra step of scheduling installation, but given how easy Tire Rack makes it, most folks don’t mind. Overall, Tire Rack is a fantastic option if you want a huge selection and value-packed deal – especially for people comfortable shopping online and looking for perks like that free 2-year hazard protection.
👉 Tire Rack Tip: Browse Tire Rack’s Special Offers page to see current rebates and discounts. For example, you might find offers such as “Get a \$70 prepaid card with purchase of 4 Michelin tires” or other brand-specific deals. Since Tire Rack includes the road hazard coverage and ships for free, factor those savings in when comparing against local store prices – it often tilts the value in Tire Rack’s favor for an affordable tire package.
SimpleTire
SimpleTire is a relative newcomer that has quickly made a name as one of the best places to find cheap tire deals online. Founded in 2012, SimpleTire’s mission is right in the name – to make buying tires simple. They connect consumers with a vast network of tire distributors and local installers through a seamless online platform. If you’re hunting for a bargain or a hard-to-find tire, SimpleTire might be your go-to. Let’s see what they offer:
-
Price & Deals: SimpleTire often has some of the lowest prices on tires, thanks to their network of over 55 million tires in stock from 300+ brands. They even have a best price guarantee – if you somehow find a tire cheaper elsewhere, they’ll match it. On top of everyday low pricing, SimpleTire is known for frequent promotions. They regularly run discount codes and seasonal sales (for example, a site-wide 10% off during Memorial Day weekend or other holidays). They also sometimes offer special perks like free tire replacement coverage on select brands during promotions – essentially giving you a road hazard warranty at no charge for those tires. Additionally, SimpleTire provides a 5% military discount for service members and veterans, and you can often stack manufacturer rebates (e.g. “buy 4, get \$50 back” offers) on top of their discounts. All these deals make it possible to save a bundle. Importantly, shipping is fast and free on all tires (excluding some oversized tires), so the price you see is usually the price you pay – no surprise shipping fees. SimpleTire’s combination of low prices + free shipping + promo codes can yield some of the most affordable tire deals around.
-
Installation & Warranty: Like Tire Rack, SimpleTire is an online seller and doesn’t install tires themselves – but they make it easy to get your tires put on. They partner with over 20,000 service centers nationwide. You can choose a local installer through their site, and have the tires shipped there directly for convenience. Many of these partners will show their installation prices up front on SimpleTire’s site, so you know the full cost. When it comes to warranties, every tire comes with the standard manufacturer’s treadwear warranty if applicable, and SimpleTire also offers an optional Road Hazard Protection plan. Their plan provides 3 years of prorated coverage (up to \$400 per tire) for damage like punctures or blowouts – it’s a paid add-on at checkout if you want extra peace of mind. If you don’t purchase that, you can still rest easy during promotions when they occasionally include road hazard coverage for free on certain brands (as mentioned above). SimpleTire also allows no-hassle returns within 30 days if the tires are unused/unmounted – for example, if you ordered the wrong size, you can send them back. This flexibility removes some risk from buying online.
-
Customer Reviews: Despite being newer, SimpleTire has racked up excellent customer reviews. In fact, over 155,000 verified customers have rated SimpleTire, with an average score of 4.8 out of 5 stars. That’s an impressive satisfaction level. Customers often highlight the low prices, easy ordering process, and quick delivery. People also like the extensive choice of tires – including niche or less-common tire models that local shops might not carry. On the flip side, because SimpleTire doesn’t have physical stores, any post-purchase services (like rotations or flat fixes) will be on you to arrange (often at a cost, unless you have a warranty). Some customers handle this by building a relationship with a local installer – you buy from SimpleTire and bring the tires there for install and future service. Overall, SimpleTire’s strong reviews show that buyers appreciate the value and convenience. It’s a great option if you’re comfortable online shopping and want to maximize your savings on a new set of tires.
👉 SimpleTire Tip: Sign up for SimpleTire’s email or check their homepage for promo codes before buying – they frequently have an extra discount available. Also, take advantage of their filtering tools and reviews on the site; with so many options in stock, filtering by price, brand, or rating can help you zero in on the best affordable tires for your needs. Once you find a deal you like, grab it – inventory can move fast during big sales!
Tire Deals Comparison Table
To help you see the differences at a glance, here’s a quick comparison of these four retailers and what value they offer:
| Retailer | Pricing & Deals | Warranty & Perks | Installation/Shipping | Customer Satisfaction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mavis Discount Tire | – Everyday low prices, frequent brand rebates (e.g. up to \$180 off Goodyear). – 110% Price Match (refund difference +5% within 30 days). – Online coupons & seasonal promos available. |
– Free lifetime rotations with purchase. – Road hazard warranty available for purchase. – Full service (alignments, brakes, etc.) offered in-shop. |
– 1400+ stores nationwide for in-person service. – Buy online or in-store, get same-day installation in many cases. – No direct shipping (must use Mavis locations for service). |
– Mixed reviews; valued for convenience & price. – Check local store reviews for quality of service (varies by location). – Not top-rated in national surveys, but many happy customers regionally. |
| Discount Tire | – Competitive pricing; will match or beat local competitors. – Frequent sales (e.g. \$80 off Michelin sets) and manufacturer rebates. – Financing options available (store credit card promos). |
– Free rotation, balancing, flat repairs, air checks for life. – Optional Certificates (road hazard protection) at extra cost. – 30-day ride guarantees on select brands (satisfaction focus). |
– 1000+ stores (Discount/America’s Tire) nationwide for easy access. – Buy online and schedule install at your chosen store. – No shipping to home (must use a store for installation). |
– Excellent ratings (among top in Consumer Reports). – Customers praise friendly service and reliability. – Tire-focused experts (no upselling of unrelated repairs). |
| Tire Rack | – Competitive online prices + free 2-year road hazard included (built-in savings). – Lists all manufacturer rebates (e.g. \$80 back on Goodyear); frequent special offers page. – Free shipping on most orders (saves on delivery cost). |
– 30-day return policy if not satisfied. – Included road hazard warranty (covers flats/punctures) for 2 years. – Standard manufacturer warranties on tires apply (honored via Tire Rack/partners). |
– Online-only; ships free to your home or one of 10,000+ partner installers. – Wide installer network; schedule installation locally after delivery. – Fast shipping (often 1-2 days if a warehouse is nearby). |
– Highly rated (part of Discount Tire’s top-ranked family). – Trusted by enthusiasts for 40+ years; known for extensive tire reviews and testing data. – Convenient and informative buying experience, but requires a separate install step. |
| SimpleTire | – Often lowest prices online; aggressive deals. – Low Price Guarantee (will match lower prices). – Frequent promo codes (5–10% off) & special deals (e.g. free hazard coverage on certain brands). – Free shipping on all tires (no hidden fees). |
– Optional 3-year road hazard protection available (covers up to \$400/tire). – 30-day easy returns on unmounted tires. – Standard manufacturer warranties on all tires. |
– Online-only; free ship to home or directly to one of 20,000+ partner installers. – Wide installer network; you can schedule installation at checkout. – No physical stores, so post-purchase service (rotations, etc.) is via local shops. |
– Excellent reviews (4.8★ average from 155k+ customers). – Customers love the savings and ease of use. – Growing reputation as a go-to for affordable tires; just plan for your own tire maintenance after purchase. |
(Stars ★ above denote average customer ratings out of 5.)
As you can see, each retailer brings something to the table for bargain-seekers. Mavis and Discount Tire offer the convenience of local service centers and things like free rotations, while Tire Rack and SimpleTire leverage the efficiency of online sales with perks like free shipping or hazard protection. All four have options to save you money – it really comes down to what you value most.
Making Your Choice: Where to Get the Best Tire Deal
At the end of the day, the best place to buy your new tires depends on your priorities:
-
If you want the lowest upfront price and don’t mind handling installation separately, an online retailer like SimpleTire (with its deep discounts and free shipping) could be your best bet. You’ll likely save the most cash here, especially during a big sale.
-
If you prefer a mix of value and service, Discount Tire is hard to beat. You’ll get a great price (and they’ll match others), plus all those free lifetime services that will save you money and time down the road. Their customer satisfaction is top-tier, which adds peace of mind.
-
If you’re all about getting extras for your money, consider Tire Rack. The free 2-year road hazard warranty and extensive tire choices make their deals a great value – you’re covered if something happens to your tires, and you benefit from their expertise and reviews.
-
If you like in-person convenience and see a big rebate on the brand you want, Mavis might be the one. You can get your tires installed the same day and take advantage of rebates or coupons to lower the cost. Just be sure your local shop is well-reviewed so you know you’ll get good service.
Bottom line: All these retailers can offer affordable tire deals. The key is to match their strengths to your needs. Do you care more about ongoing free services, or simply the lowest price today? Are you comfortable buying online, or do you prefer a local touch? By comparing pricing, warranties, discounts, and reviews (as we’ve done above), you’re already well on your way to making an informed choice.
Before you pull the trigger, double-check for any current promotions at your chosen retailer – tire deals change often, especially around holidays. A little timing and research can save you even more. Once you’ve found your winner, go ahead and get those new tires. You’ll be back on the road with better grip, a safer ride, and the satisfaction of knowing you got a great deal.
Happy tire shopping, and safe driving on those new wheels!
