Best Year Subaru Legacy: Are They Actually Any Better? (2023)

(Last Updated On: October 23, 2023)

‍Sedan lovers the world over have always had a soft spot for Subaru Legacy. This beloved model has seen its fair share of iterations, but which reigns supreme? With continual advancements, does the legend of the past outshine the technology of the present? As we navigate the rustling lanes of the auto industry, we delve into the best year Subaru Legacy, and answer – are they actually any better now?

So buckle up as we unravel the evolution, dissect the differences and undercurrents of the Legacy – reminding you why you fell in love with this enduring emblem of Subaru in the first place. Prepare to fuel your curiosity, rev your engine, and drive through the annals of Legacy’s history. Hang onto your hats, it’s going to be quite the ride!

What Are The Best Years for The Subaru Legacy?

Over three decades of production means that there are numerous Subaru Legacy models to choose from. Here, we explore the standout years of the Subaru Legacy, examining their unique selling points and why they are considered the best.

The 2004 Subaru Legacy

A Reliable Performer

The 2004 Legacy, part of the third-generation lineup, is a well-balanced car offering excellent handling and steering. Its 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine might not be the most thrilling, but it’s dependable. The 2004 Legacy has earned a reputation for being the most reliable model in this generation, boasting decent fuel economy and durability ratings.

A Value for Money Proposition

With used models ranging from $3,050 – $4,150, the 2004 Legacy offers fantastic value for money. Another model worth considering in this generation is the 2000 Legacy – while more basic in appearance, it still offers reliability and could be an excellent first car for young drivers.

The 2006 and 2007 Subaru Legacy

Standouts in Reliability

The years 2005-2009 were generally good for the Legacy sedan, but the 2006 and 2007 models stood out in terms of reliability. Both the 2006 and 2007 Subaru Legacy models received the “Seal of Awesome” award from CarComplaints.com, indicating their exceptional reliability ratings and fuel economy.

The 2013 Subaru Legacy

A Consumer Reports Pick

The 2013 Legacy, a fifth-generation model, was lauded as one of the best lineups for the midsize sedan. It was hailed as an accommodating and easy-to-live-with family sedan. Consumer Reports gave it a reliability rating of 4.0 out of 5.0, and it did well in common reliability trouble spots such as the engine, transmission, and drive system.

The 2016 and 2017 Subaru Legacy

Top Picks for the Sixth Generation

The 2016 and 2017 models are top picks in the sixth generation of the Legacy. Both models were recommended by Consumer Reports, with the 2016 model boasting a perfect reliability score. These models shared many positive qualities, including excellent visibility and standard AWD.

This ’16-’17 Model Year Legacy is widely proclaimed to be the best of them all

The 2020 Subaru Legacy

Addressing Previous Reliability Issues

The 2020 Subaru Legacy earns high praises, as it addressed many of the previous reliability issues of the sedan. It offers a solid all-around performance, a spacious interior, tech upgrades, and enhanced safety features. It also received a 4.0 out of 5.0 in reliability and 3.0 out of 5.0 in customer satisfaction from Consumer Reports.

More Subie Stuff: Are Subaru WRX Reliable? Yes and No (Here’s Why)

Why? What Changed From Previous Models?

Subaru has been committed to improving the Legacy with each new generation. Enhancements in engine technology, transmission systems, safety features, and interior comfort have all contributed to the Legacy’s evolution.


What Problems Did Other Models Encounter (Brief Summary)

While the Subaru Legacy has had many successful years, it hasn’t been without its share of problems. Issues with faulty headlights, transmission problems, and head gasket leaks have all been reported in different model years. Particularly, the 2009 and 2014 models had more reliability issues compared to other years.

Related article: What Do These Subaru Dashboard Lights Mean?

How Has The Subaru Legacy Become More Reliable Over The Years?

Subaru has been proactive in addressing the issues found in their cars. Each new generation of the Legacy sees improvements in manufacturing processes, technology, and designs that enhance reliability. The automaker’s commitment to safety and quality control has helped the Subaru Legacy become more reliable over the years.

Should You Buy A Used Subaru Legacy? Why or Why Not?

Buying a used Subaru Legacy can be a good decision, especially if you choose one of the best years mentioned above. These vehicles offer reliable performance, great features, and excellent value for money. However, like any used car purchase, it’s essential to do your due diligence, look into the vehicle’s history, and have it inspected by a professional.

Related article: Subaru Legacy Years to Avoid

What To Look For When Buying Used

When buying a used Subaru Legacy, pay attention to the vehicle’s maintenance history, check for any recalls, and look for signs of major repairs. Additionally, pay close attention to the condition of the engine and transmission, as these are the most costly parts to repair.

How Does The Forester Fare?
> Best Years for Subaru Forester
> Forester Years to Avoid

Here’s a checklist you can use to make sure all your bases are covered:

In conclusion, the Subaru Legacy has had many standout years that offer exceptional reliability, performance, and features. With careful consideration and research, you can find a used Subaru Legacy that will serve you well for many years to come. Remember, the best year Subaru Legacy for you ultimately depends on your specific needs and budget.

Keep reading: Are Subarus Expensive To Fix?


What are some of the standout years for the Subaru Legacy in terms of reliability and performance?

Some standout years include 2004, 2006-2007, 2013, 2016-2017, and 2020. These models were highlighted for their reliability, features, and performance.

What makes the 2020 Subaru Legacy notable compared to previous models?

The 2020 model addressed many of the previous reliability issues, boasting solid performance, a spacious interior, tech upgrades, and enhanced safety features.

Have there been any significant problems with the Subaru Legacy in certain model years?

Yes, some models, notably the 2009 and 2014 versions, faced more reliability issues, such as faulty headlights, transmission problems, and head gasket leaks.

How has Subaru worked to improve the Legacy’s reliability over the years?

Subaru has consistently improved the Legacy by refining manufacturing processes, enhancing technology, and updating designs. Their commitment to safety and quality control has particularly contributed to the car’s increased reliability.

Is it a good idea to buy a used Subaru Legacy, and what should potential buyers look out for?

Buying a used Subaru Legacy can be a wise choice, especially models from standout years. When purchasing, always review the vehicle’s maintenance history, check for recalls, and inspect the engine and transmission conditions.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *